
DREAM HOME BUILDING PLANS
BEFORE & AFTER
DREAM HOME PLAN DETAIL - RESIDENTIAL LIGHTING DESIGN - NIGHTLIGHTING DESIGN SCHEDULE: Residential Lighting Design for Aging Eyes
See also Residential Lighting Design - Daylighting Design Schedule
I spent an hour today at the granite knee of another - Tess Haygood - at Georgia Lighting. She's the big dog on the porch nationally for dream home plan builders and even guys like me to layout residential lighting design for a dream home plan. Among the trades with which Mrs. AG and I have worked over all these years, no trade has had more changes, more development than lighting. You want to risk value, take a fast pass on residential lighting design. You want to boost value and comfort and convenience, lean on a residential lighting design pro. They do not abound on the fruited plain. Stick around a residential lighting shop floor of size, and you'll spot one to a site - they're the go-to guru on the deck in any big-time residential lighting wholesaler and retailer if that wholesaler or retailer is attentive enough to hold onto them. Without 20 or 30 or more years before the mast, they haven't been there, done that. What an honor for me to work with a consummate professional. No hassle. No rancor. No ill will. No unanswered questions. No waffle. No detail not worth addressing forthrightly and fully. Can't wait to show you the nub of what you need to know. May not tell you twice and the one time they tell you is fast and even near to furtive and furious, because their bar is high and their time is taught. Passion about her work oozed all over our conversation. Masterly competence and confidence prevailed. When you are with the best, you know it - it all looks so easy and you know somewhere deep inside that what you witness is special, sifted and sorted down all the years, selected just for this one occasion with you, not what you're going to get again down the road. I know those nuggets of time-tested truth. Roll them out daily. Some fundamentals of a practice are not in books, they're in scar tissue, and wrinkles, and regrets of paths not taken or cares not given or assumptions unmet or expectations unexpected, and memories of witness to failures not forgotten. I am humbled in the presence of virtually unequivocal ability and capacity. I glory in the presence of excellence expected as the norm, and excellence delivered seemingly without extra effort because that extra effort is the norm. AG
· · · · · · ·
BEFORE
AG went a-searching the world wide over for words and other ways to the effect of understanding in terms of the granite knee something about dream home plan residential lighting design and, especially, residential lighting design for aging eyes. Like these guys on their way into Julian Beever's hole in a sidewalk artistry are about to find out, it's dark in there.
· · · · · · ·
AFTER
Dream Home Plan Standards Basics
1) Before The Architect is taking increasing interest in interior residential lighting design metrics, especially in residential lighting design for aging eyes
a) the majority of Before The Architect’s clients are mature, and mature individuals’ eyes as compared to eyes in youth or early- middle years
i) need more light
ii) need light presented differently
b) there is precious little guidance on this subject unless you scrounge and scrounge for accessible orts of information and insight (no pun intended)
c) the subject matter of lighting design is so over-intellectualized, nearly incoherent, and, seemingly, purposely tortuous sufficient to rewarm the innards of even your casual conspiracy theorist
2) AG created his own guidance system for residential lighting design of interiors for clients
a) rules
i) layer lighting design
ii) apply dimmer switches wherever possible
Comment: Lutron makes applying dimmer switches a whole lot easier than it used to be, including but not limited to 4-dimming involving every device in the gang.
iii) define illuminance
(1) on three levels
Comment: It’s ok to be approximate and not obsessive in this matter, so long as errs are to the high side and not the low side, noting AG’s read that a difference of 10 fc [you'll read about this term "fc" very soon} may not be ordinarily observable to most folks.
(a) 40 foot candles or lumens/foot2
Comment: Let’s get a couple of aspects of lighting design settled completely and without wiggle-room.
1 foot candle = 1 lumen/ft2 ,
o where foot candle = fc or ftc and lumen = l or lm and
o which metrics are measures of illuminance, or the perceived intensity of light or light level [fuller, fancier definitions AG has determined to be less illuminating]
All light bulbs
o whether incandescent or fluorescent
o have ratings of illuminance in terms of lumens/watt (LPW or lm/W) which is a measure of efficiency of illuminance related to the watts you pay for in bulb and electricity
o sometimes, you have to dig for this info to get where you’re going, but the work is well worth it.
AG derates published, particular lumens/watt by a 0.8 multiplier, or 20% discount (which is, in AG’s opinion, a conservative shot at so-called "maintenance lumens"), for
o merchandising hype
o resistance wear over time,
o dirt accumulation
(b) 70 foot candles
(c) 100 foot candles
(2) stick to photometric analysis until AG can make sense of radiometric analysis and scrape together enough lunch money to afford the software to reckon it
(3) in specific arrangement such that
(a) in-between abutting spaces, the fc change
(i) shall be no greater than 30 fc
(ii) may grade up or down in levels less than 30 fc in the interims
(b) within spaces and across spaces, bare bulbs shall not be casually observable (essentially recognizing that brightness and glare are not the same)
(4) for specific areas
(a) hallways and most common and privates spaces get 40 fc
(b) moving-around areas of bathrooms, kitchens, utility spaces get 70 fc
(c) work areas such as
(i) kitchens
(ii) bathrooms
(iii) laundries
(iv) workshops
(v) counters and other work surfaces
(vi) PLUS 1 linear foot outset from those surfaces gets 100 fc
(5) in specific functionality
(a) ambient for most spaces
(b) task for work areas
(c) AG leaves most or all dramatic lighting design to clients and lighting design pros
(6) in specific formulations of lighting design quality
(a) ambient means accepting as minimums
(i) Color Rendering Index (CRI) not less than 80, preferably not less than 90
(ii) Correlated Color Temperature (CCT) not greater than 3000K (a/k/a Kelvin)
(b) task mean accepting as maximums
(i) Color Rendering Index (CRI) not more than 90, preferably not greater than 80
(ii) Correlated Color Temperature (CCT) not less than 3000K (a/k/a Kelvin)
3) The math [hang on mathphobes, this stuff boils down to one number times another number equals a third number - like 2x6=6, like - that you can take to a lighting design professional who can deliver the illuminance goods]
a) AG’s made up what are in his opinion a reasonable set of rules and restrictions for residential interior lighting design in order
i) to achieve interior lighting design standards more suitable to aging eyes (which the literature allows begin to need extra light in the 40s)
ii) to translate those standards into numerical targets of commonplace metrics readily available in the retail marketplace
(1) lumens/watt data have been around quite a while now
(2) CRI and CCT data were hard come-by up until the last few years, particularly as fluorescent manufacturers "warmed up" their bulbs, and particularly thereat their compact fluorescent lamps or CFLs
b) foot candle target value – 40, 70, or 100 – multiplied by the surface area to be so lighted equals the lumen value to be achieved by so many light bulbs producing their rated lumens/Watt multiplied by 0.8
i) AG is not immediately interested in how the space gets lighted
(1) not the specific luminaires
(2) not their placement
ii) AG is immediately interested in determining lumens for given spaces
Residential Lighting Design Schedule - Interior and Covered Porch
4) Worth mentioning
a) some spaces get both ambient lighting design and task lighting design targets, such as baths, as referenced above
b) Dining and Dining Table are distinguished since they may be lighted separately as well as together
c) Kitchen is estimated because as of this schedules authorship, kitchen design was being done by others and without definite preview
d) dramatic lighting design is to be done by others
5) This lighting design schedule came with extensive notes
Notes to Residential Lighting Design Schedule - Interior and Covered Porch
6) The Schedule and related notes get translated in the Electrical Plan in plan view, as excerpted below
Lighting Design Highlights in an Electrical Plan, View
7) Let’s inspect this drawing for conformity to our lighting design standards
a) all but 2 wall switches are "D" for dimmer
b) switches between bath and bed (space to the left and above) are "L" for lighted
c) vanity lighting design is properly set at 66 linear inches over finish floor level and luminaires are spaced 30 linear inches apart and centered over the lavatories
d) the closet switch is pressure-sensitive, relieving occupants from excess visual and physical distraction in moving between spaces
e) foot candles (a/k/a lumens) are clearly identified by space, value, and type
f) distinction is clearly made that luminaires are illustrative, i.e., final choices of luminaire types, numbers, and sites are to be done by others whose day job it is to do so
g) centerlines are depicted for certain lighting design groups because AG and The Missus have abundant experience in observing how cock-eyed some luminaires get applied when left to mechanics
h) luminaire site (with notable exception), number, make, and model are really only defined in terms of minimum illuminance, and, as drawn, are explicitly illustrative
Comment: In the experience of both AG and The Missus, lighting design technology progresses more quickly than any other in the realm of residential design and custom home building. In other words, final layouts of lighting design have to be done by others for clients to get the greater benefit.
Comment: Since authoring this work, it's minorly but importantly amended in one respect; namely, that in task spaces, e.g., baths, kitchens, where ambient lighting design may be 70 fc, the proximate task area shall have not less than 40 fc illuminance on a standalone basis, i.e., even without the ambient lighting design in service. In other words, all-on illuminance can be not less than 110 fc.
· · · · · · ·
Note, please, that this information is included in Home Design Standards - Home Building Standards starting in the 2Q08 edition, and additionally includes a plan view depiction and analytic schematic on light flutter plus a comprehensive, comparative graph of lighting design efficiency by type of light source and a comparative table on lighting design quality again by type of light source.
· · · · · · ·
About Us ◊ jrp2h2000@yahoo.com ◊ 770-889-6964 ◊ 2985 Heatherwyn Way, Cumming, GA 30040
(If this is your first visit to Before The Architect, please consider spending a few moments looking over the Site Map, in order to get a feel for the architecture of the site itself. Before The Architect E-mail: jrp2h2000@yahoo.com.)